| L1 | 2025-2026 | 26/12/2025 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-1 | Rotherham United | Josh Sheehan, Josh Sheehan | Highlights | 23,416 | Win |
| EFLT | 2025-2026 | 02/09/2025 | Bolton Wanderers | 1-0 | Rotherham United | Thierry Gale | Highlights | 2,063 | Win |
| L1 | 2024-2025 | 08/04/2025 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-1 | Rotherham United | | Highlights | 19,218 | Loss |
| L1 | 2024-2025 | 11/01/2025 | Rotherham United | 3-1 | Bolton Wanderers | John McAtee | Highlights | 10,258 | Loss |
| L1 | 2021-2022 | 01/01/2022 | Rotherham United | 2-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Eoin Doyle | Highlights | 9,736 | Loss |
| L1 | 2021-2022 | 18/09/2021 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-2 | Rotherham United | | Highlights | 20,877 | Loss |
| L1 | 2019-2020 | 14/09/2019 | Rotherham United | 6-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Thibaud Verlinden | Highlights | 10,088 | Loss |
| C | 2018-2019 | 26/12/2018 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-1 | Rotherham United | Sammy Ameobi, Gary O'Neil | Highlights | 15,255 | Win |
| C | 2018-2019 | 20/10/2018 | Rotherham United | 1-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Christian Doidge | Highlights | 10,011 | Draw |
| C | 2015-2016 | 06/02/2016 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-1 | Rotherham United | Jay Spearing, Kaiyne Woolery | Highlights | 14,641 | Win |
| C | 2015-2016 | 26/12/2015 | Rotherham United | 4-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | Highlights | 11,315 | Loss |
| C | 2014-2015 | 27/01/2015 | Rotherham United | 4-2 | Bolton Wanderers | Liam Trotter, Matt Mills | Highlights | 8,760 | Loss |
| C | 2014-2015 | 16/09/2014 | Bolton Wanderers | 3-2 | Rotherham United | Mason 3 | Highlights | 13,630 | Win |
| D2 | 1992-1993 | 30/03/1993 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-0 | Rotherham United | Walker A 2 (1 pen) | | 7,985 | Win |
| D2 | 1992-1993 | 12/09/1992 | Rotherham United | 2-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Brown P | | 5,227 | Loss |
| D3 | 1990-1991 | 27/04/1991 | Rotherham United | 2-2 | Bolton Wanderers | Cunningham 2 | | 8,045 | Draw |
| D3 | 1990-1991 | 23/10/1990 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-0 | Rotherham United | | | 4,692 | Draw |
| D3 | 1989-1990 | 10/02/1990 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-2 | Rotherham United | | | 7,728 | Loss |
| AMCNQF | 1989-1990 | 31/01/1990 | Bolton Wanderers | 1-0 | Rotherham United | Storer | | 6,838 | Win |
| D3 | 1989-1990 | 16/09/1989 | Rotherham United | 1-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 6,846 | Loss |
| D3 | 1986-1987 | 14/03/1987 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-0 | Rotherham United | | | 3,748 | Draw |
| D3 | 1986-1987 | 18/10/1986 | Rotherham United | 1-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 3,430 | Loss |
| D3 | 1985-1986 | 18/01/1986 | Rotherham United | 4-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 3,821 | Loss |
| D3 | 1985-1986 | 17/08/1985 | Bolton Wanderers | 1-1 | Rotherham United | Caldwell | | 5,129 | Draw |
| D3 | 1984-1985 | 26/01/1985 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-0 | Rotherham United | Caldwell 2 | | 5,059 | Win |
| D3 | 1984-1985 | 15/09/1984 | Rotherham United | 3-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Oghani | | 3,926 | Loss |
| D3 | 1983-1984 | 11/02/1984 | Rotherham United | 1-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Rudge | | 5,043 | Draw |
| D3 | 1983-1984 | 24/09/1983 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-0 | Rotherham United | Caldwell, Redfearn | | 5,592 | Win |
| D2 | 1982-1983 | 19/02/1983 | Rotherham United | 1-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Chandler | | 5,646 | Draw |
| D2 | 1982-1983 | 09/10/1982 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-2 | Rotherham United | Thompson C, Moores I | | 6,577 | Draw |
| D2 | 1981-1982 | 20/02/1982 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-1 | Rotherham United | | | 9,466 | Loss |
| D2 | 1981-1982 | 26/09/1981 | Rotherham United | 2-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 6,998 | Loss |
| D3 | 1972-1973 | 31/03/1973 | Rotherham United | 1-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 6,506 | Loss |
| D3 | 1972-1973 | 25/11/1972 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-1 | Rotherham United | Byrom, Jones G | | 7,980 | Win |
| D3 | 1971-1972 | 02/05/1972 | Rotherham United | 2-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 3,945 | Loss |
| D3 | 1971-1972 | 29/04/1972 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-2 | Rotherham United | Phillips R 2 | | 5,345 | Draw |
| LC2R2 | 1969-1970 | 11/09/1969 | Rotherham United | 1-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 9,018 | Loss |
| LC2R | 1969-1970 | 09/09/1969 | Rotherham United | 3-3 | Bolton Wanderers | Hulme J, Byrom 2 (aet) | | 7,924 | Draw |
| LC2 | 1969-1970 | 03/09/1969 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-0 | Rotherham United | | | 11,043 | Draw |
| D2 | 1967-1968 | 16/03/1968 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-2 | Rotherham United | | | 8,682 | Loss |
| D2 | 1967-1968 | 21/10/1967 | Rotherham United | 2-2 | Bolton Wanderers | Greaves, Byrom | | 7,229 | Draw |
| D2 | 1966-1967 | 30/08/1966 | Rotherham United | 0-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Taylor G | | 11,943 | Win |
| D2 | 1966-1967 | 24/08/1966 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-2 | Rotherham United | Davies W, Hill | | 14,389 | Draw |
| D2 | 1965-1966 | 25/04/1966 | Bolton Wanderers | 1-3 | Rotherham United | Davies W | | 10,622 | Loss |
| D2 | 1965-1966 | 27/11/1965 | Rotherham United | 2-1 | Bolton Wanderers | Redrobe | | 9,785 | Loss |
| D2 | 1964-1965 | 17/04/1965 | Rotherham United | 0-0 | Bolton Wanderers | | | 7,685 | Draw |
| D2 | 1964-1965 | 24/10/1964 | Bolton Wanderers | 2-0 | Rotherham United | Lee F (pen), Taylor G | | 14,173 | Win |
| LC4 | 1960-1961 | 20/12/1960 | Bolton Wanderers | 0-2 | Rotherham United | | | 6,594 | Loss |